All I can suggest is run a comparison yourself. If you have an even # of miners, point half here and half there, and after a month, compare the results. The important thing is to test for at least a month, otherwise variance will skew the numbers. Even then, it may still skew it.
I would not go by what's stated here in the pool by members. Who knows if their calculations are accurate? Furthermore, I wouldn't go by any 3rd party site.
M
FWIW I ran on NiceHash for the first week of November and they were paying in the range of .00018 - .000185 per TH/day throughout that time.
...
Nicehash lies on their web site.
As I've mentioned before, during October, myself and another person (to our, and everyone elses misfortune) used nicehash to push the hash rate up, to get past those 2 long blocks.
During that time I never paid more than 101% PPS on the market, so the miners were getting 98% PPS - of course I had to pay nicehash 104% PPS ... yeah people don't see those obscured extra costs/losses ...
During that time, mining anywhere
with 100% luck, would get you over 107% PPS before fees.
As for what the pool gets, well it doesn't matter what anyone states, just look at the web site - it will tell you block ranges and months.