It's probably a change address used by the wallet. Change addresses are what allows you to not only spend large chunks of Bitcoin at once. Unless your balance has decreased more than you expected it, you should be fine.
I should have received 0.27298966 BTC which is 0.27459522 BTC being sent minus the miner's fee, but there are 0.26861186 BTC in my balance on Bittrex.
Should I contact them?