Well... as someone who has donated 25 btc to EFF, I am qualified to comment.
When I first started using bitcoins, The Faucet gave me .05. Id did get me started... so I do have some sympathy.
But not enough to donate 5000 times more than I got out of it.
What do I want? I want the EFF to accept bitcoins. Cash what you have... or, return to the donors accounts.
I donated 10 BTC back when they were about $1 each. Given the rise in value since then, if the EFF does not want them, I would prefer to get mine back.
In my case sending the coins back to any of the addresses they came from would accomplish that.
When I first found out about bitcoin I could not get the faucet to work for me. So I do not feel any need to donate to it, and certainly not $120+ worth of bitcoins.