It seems like it shouldn't matter if the altcoin is premined or not.
It depends on what the premine is for. Sometimes developers use a premine for bounties and other events to promote the coin. However some may just premine to keep a lot of coins to themselves. This could be bad for several reasons. For example, what if the developer premined a lot of the coin and dropped all their coins at once? That would really hurt the price of the coin.