is this a final decission from CMC or what could we do, that this will be changed ?
It's clear that the cmc circulating supply is a battle of interpretation between the two parties. Go under the FAQ of the cmc site, and look for this question "
Why is the Circulating Supply used in determining the market capitalization instead of Total Supply? "
CMC uses the public float to determine the market cap. It's clear that they see the November 2nd virtual fork free coins that have not yet been redeemed as locked coins. Therefore, according to their definition of market cap these non-redeemed coins are not accounted for the circulating supply.
Is it fair compared to all BTC forks? Absolutely not!
It's not a interpretation at all, its just wrong. If you left your purse at you grandparents place which you visit just once a year, or maybe never again, that money is still circulating and in public float, does not matter if you have access to it or not. It's there!
Same with the virtual fork, at the time of importing the BTC snapshot the devs made these coins public float.
Different point of view, how could anybody check how much coin are redeemed and how much not? So they will never be in circulation?