Post
Topic
Board Pools
Re: [37000 GH] BTC Guild - PPS/PPLNS + TxFees, Stratum, Merged Mining ASIC Tested
by
os2sam
on 02/07/2013, 22:58:17 UTC
I strongly recommend BFGMINER for USB Block Erupters.

BFGMiner may well be just fine.

But I cannot believe it is easier nor more reliable than CGMiner.  The install was the easiest miner setup I have ever done, with any mining program including Ufasoft.  I am running 3 instances to three pools 2 Erupters each.  Maybe since I don't have a high number of devices I'm not seeing issues others may be having??

Mapping Erupters as serial ports has to be problematic as the serial port mappings will change at Windoze' whim on a reboot which would cause major problems with multiple instances of a miner.

Win7 32 bit
CGMiner 3.3.1
2 Rosewill USB 2.0 7 port hubs.
Sam

The problem is the -newest- cgminer requires more than just mapping them to COM ports.  It uses WinUSB on top of the other tool that maps them.  As a result it's fully hotpluggable, but adds an extra hoop and sometimes requires you to run an extra tool to re-assign WinUSB when you change ports/add more units.  Meanwhile, bfgminer only uses the software that makes them show up as COM ports, and you run '-S all' to have it scan/recognize all of them at once.

Older cgminer verisons work the same as bfgminer as far as I'm aware, it's only the newest version that added extra steps (newest cgminer does not have -S at all).

My experience with installing USB serial drivers  and having them stay mapped to a particular comm port is more like hoops with flames.

Whereas using the Zadig utility is a one time event you never have to repeat again.  I just don't see the validity in the comparison.

I'm not trying to be difficult, nor say anything disparaging about BFGMiner, but CGMiner setup is not as problematic as many have MADE it out to be.

One caveat in my experience, the Block Erupters are my first USB mining devices so I had no baggage from previous installs/configurations.
Sam