Odd...how much did you overclock?
Paste OverdriveNtool.ini or your settings for memclock etc.
nothing extreme

as I said 16 others works just fine !
Hate to ask this, but I'm assuming you already did DDU, reinstalled drivers, tried a different PCI slot.
My guess is the card is suspect. Can you isolate this card on another system by itself to see if the issue carries over?