Post
Topic
Board Development & Technical Discussion
Re: stupid question: why not move transactions outside blocks ?
by
wpwrak
on 30/12/2017, 18:50:54 UTC
Maybe I misunderstand you, but what you describe sounds pretty close to what SegWit is already doing:

https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0141.mediawiki

Hmm, I'm still struggling to understand what SegWit exactly is :-) The BIP touches a lot of issues and suggests many future developments, so I'm not sure how much of what SegWit is intended to do is actually implemented.

One explanation I found basically describes it as an accounting trick: you move part of the data in the block to a different place and declare bytes there to be smaller than bytes elsewhere, which allows you to grow blocks a little without exceeding the 1 MB limit. But, if I understand this right, the transactions would still be part of the same block.

If SegWit allows most of the transaction data to travel through a different channel, then it would be indeed what I've been looking for.

Thanks !

- Werner