Really?! Did you get your confirmation e-mail after the withdrawal?
EDIT: OMFG. I just randomly tried something: disabling 2FA. Once I did that, I got a message saying I would get an e-mail (message I've never seen before with 2FA activated) - then I've confirmed the withdrawal on my e-mail and 3 seconds later it was on my Exodus wallet! AWESOME!
Thats strange, because I had the 2FA, and it worked though.
Anyway, if we have our coins back, it's the only thing we need to know
