First, your pool idea (auto conversion to bitcoins) is great. I's like to see you get as much traffic as possible to reward your efforts.

I appreciate that you believe that they "are in fact" more profitable (I'm sure under some scenario they are), that's just not the results that I and a lot of others experience. After all results are considered, the net result is certainly very low profit for me, with ample evidence. The data is very clear. I'm not complaining about a high reject rate; I'm complaining about poor mining results. My reject rates seem typical for the pool, and yes everyone's rates go up when these coins get mined. I'm concerned about results, not rejects (they are just a symptom).

I submit to you that the lower payouts you notice on the pool overall have a lot to do with this problem. I have spent many hours studying the pool results, minute(s) by minute(s), during the mining of the various coins, and absolutely see a strong correlation. Please consider this a real problem, even though you seem to believe that it is not. I want to stay in your pool, but this makes it much less economical.