Joey, what are you going to do if windows (or other things) in your house start breaking in the middle of the night? How are you going to afford to fix them? Will you have to move to a rent controlled complex where your activities won't be allowed?
If you continue to scam people, it's going to happen. You can't break the law and expect everyone else to follow it.
Our house is insured.
I'm sure you have deductibles on your insurance policy.

$500 out of your pocket for every incident.
Go ahead and go to the police. Do you think they will ask why it's happening? Eventually they are going to find out that you are an active fraudster and charge YOU.
I don't think it's going to stop windows from breaking in your house in the wee hours of the morning.

No deductibles. And if they get broken we will collect insurance money and just board them up.
Smashing a car through our house would be a lotto win for us. The insurance is worth $200,000 but the house and everything in it isn't even worth $20,000.
BULLSHIT. You couldn't afford a no deductible policy.
I can't wait for a pic of your house with all windows boarded up and a sign on the front door saying "Unfit for human occupancy".

Hopefully the people visiting you will be more creative, such as breaking down your doors, or smashing a stolen car through the front of the house.