I appreciate that you believe that they "are in fact" more profitable (I'm sure under some scenario they are), that's just not the results that I and a lot of others experience.
...
I definitely want to look at it.
A major flaw right now in the pool, and one that I'm currently working on, is proper reporting. While the math says that a certain coin is more profitable, I don't have any easy way to tell for sure, other than doing painstaking manual database lookups.
What I really need is a profit graph. Then I can see where it dips, and what coin we were at then.
Per your request, I have produced some graphs of your pool's mining productivity for your perusal. Please PM me for info if you are still interested.