PS: Just to clarify, only admins can lift bans here, not moderators. I usually consult with theymos on stuff like this though, and would prefer to leave the decision to him here.
Which is perfectly understandable.
You were not the one banning him for
voicing out his opinion about this Garr255 scam thing trolling...
I wish you were in charge here, actually.
Ooops, did I just troll?

Seriously, theymos, I understand you might have felt uneasy about some of his posts, but this really looks like an abuse of power.
You need to let people express what they think, including conspiracy theories about you, too.
That's one of the burdens that comes with your position.
If people were not globally trusting you, this forum wouldn't be the shade of what it is, you're safe and don't have to fear those random rants!
Please relax and reconsider!

Well, to be honest here I don't think theymos can please everyone.
I remember that we got a lot of requests for Matthew to be banned after the Pirate event too. I guess if we went for the all-ban policy for scammers Matthew wouldn't be around to amend his bet by repaying partially here...