I don't have any doubt that what theymos saw was a real person doing what was required for a verification, I doubt it was completely faked, but this is why I PM'd theymos as he may have the best insight, I don't use GirlsGoneBitcoin. There are still plausible scenarios where one could get verified using images or videos they paid for, from friends taking a cut, blackmail, etc. E-Whoring seems to be getting more sophisticated these days, the verification through theymos may have been the hardest (or most costly) piece but certainly not impossible.

A better question may be "Why is there a 15 year old boy asking for a fake ID matching the name of an e-whore who appeared on this forum a week after that 15 year old boy asked for it"