There is only one problem with this list. If someone out there who wanted to manipulate the total lost/stolen coins, they could PM you, lie and say they had 50,000 coins on the pool for example. You have only their word on this as there is no proof on how many coins were actually on the pool.
We need a list of lost/stolen coins but also proof to back it up.
That's true, though I'm not sure what would constitute proof of mining on a pool, without the operator's own records. And since the operator is saying they won't even pay, it seems to reduce incentive to invent a claim. I'll apply some discretion to tracking further claims, only within the next 24 hours or so, and any extra-large ones are implicitly subject to reputation (so Anonymous has to be taken with a grain of salt).
If Lollaskates decides to come up with some funds, he can review the time sequence/reputation of posters.
To avoid cluttering this thread, I moved the tally list to:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=276707.0For further updates/claims on the pool situation, please post over there.