Post
Topic
Board Meta
Merits 41 from 16 users
Topic OP
Merit stat & all transactions more than 40 Merits
by
sncc
on 01/03/2018, 16:47:15 UTC
⭐ Merited by Vod (10) ,DarkStar_ (8) ,dbshck (5) ,EFS (3) ,EcuaMobi (2) ,Tyrantt (2) ,dillpicklechips (2) ,elma (1) ,coinlocket$ (1) ,Linuld (1) ,sapta (1) ,LoyceV (1) ,bitmover (1) ,LFC_Bitcoin (1) ,marlboroza (1) ,malevolent (1)
Update: 2018/05/09

The tables below are updated to include the most recent transactions, while the graphs and numbers are kept as the original post. 

Link to tables



Merit raw data is now available:

Here you go: https://bitcointalk.org/merit.txt.xz

Similar to trust.txt.xz, it'll be updated weekly. It will show only the last 120 days of data; someone else should archive the old ones if you want them.

I am especially interested in analyses of this data which could point to sub-communities where the initial sMerit is exhausted and new sources are necessary, and people who might be good merit sources.

Edit: Note that for a little while I had user_to and user_from as names, but I decided to change it to IDs.



By using the data, I created a histogram of the distribution of the number of users who sent 1-50 sMerits:

https://i.imgur.com/tliiyaH


https://i.imgur.com/kLJYU5e




Clearly, 1 Merit is the most popular choice, but it is interesting to see that the histogram is not monotonically decreasing.
Top 10 amounts of sent merits are as follows:

Amount   # of Users
126035
24939
52156
31485
10866
4750
6245
20216
7138
50102

On the other hand, no one sent 37, 46, 47 Merits, two of which are prime numbers, presumably implying that people un/consciously do not like big prime numbers and prefer good cut-off point.



In total 85524 sMerits have been sent.
This number is much larger than 11975 sMerits, which are currently created by 57 merit sources per month.
The sMerits created by 57 merit sources are not sufficient and most of used sMerits were initially assigned ones.
This fact suggests that we need more merit sources and/or more sMerits per source.



We see that there is a peak at the upper limit of 50 Merit, some of which may be abuse of merit.
For those who want to check them, I created a clickable table of all transactions more than 40 sMerits.

Update: 2018/05/09

50 Merit transactions
yyyy/mm/ddhh:mm:ssUser_FromPostUser_To
2018/04/3002:13:51ICOcountdown.com->Rugosa
2018/04/2910:45:38hhk1045->anonymous3x
2018/04/2616:02:35George5->DrCharles
2018/04/2412:44:16chronicsky->sourish
2018/04/2410:43:28bumbacoin->satoshi
2018/04/2314:51:18Jasad->Denies
2018/04/2304:49:31dazedfool->TMAN
2018/04/2004:35:51bitpop->suchmoon
2018/04/2003:46:53HCLivess->Hal
2018/04/1614:29:52Rumhurius->popshot
2018/04/1506:31:10rorschach1->CryptonikaTrade
2018/04/1416:33:59Taxidermista->brianmct
2018/04/1315:35:15boltz->Eclipse2021
2018/04/1214:07:54iTradeChips->JaoBadjap
2018/04/1106:16:57generalizethis->cryptimus prime
2018/04/0909:03:20Claymore->satoshi
2018/04/0808:15:37Cazkys->Nerobasta
2018/04/0615:01:27sardokan->LeGaulois
2018/04/0606:44:27Jumbley->DigiByte
2018/04/0515:44:02jackielove4u->ocminer
2018/04/0416:26:43DaveyJones->unknownids
2018/04/0407:21:02valtin->winterrose
2018/04/0319:04:54goxed->GameKyuubi
2018/03/3117:12:53Hyperjacked->heratys111
2018/03/3108:25:26CryptKeeper->tonych
2018/03/3016:32:42bonosurgut->BigBoozie
2018/03/3010:52:361Referee->ChipMixer
2018/03/3010:49:221Referee->satoshi
2018/03/3008:30:19sardokan->superresistant
2018/03/2815:51:54Southpaw0->zazarb
2018/03/2806:26:44notbatman->monero
2018/03/2709:20:29HCLivess->gawlea
2018/03/2619:10:53Mr.Net->Arysum
2018/03/2522:04:14HostFat->gallisiardi
2018/03/2520:00:02Phore->moonshoot
2018/03/2412:34:54CrackedLogic->btcnerdie
2018/03/2310:39:42ekoja->miramare
2018/03/2222:55:28Rumhurius->LimxDev
2018/03/2118:27:36Rumhurius->bytemaster
2018/03/2107:22:18mrhelpful->allinvain
2018/03/1912:59:31pinkpanther03->Wingzcrypto2018
2018/03/1910:59:43cryptodevil->suchmoon
2018/03/1910:47:53cryptodevil->spartak_t
2018/03/1814:32:30finist4x->aliborn
2018/03/1602:53:47BitcoinEXpress->Vod
2018/03/1518:14:54gordonhill->Kreds
2018/03/1514:33:39publicjud->proexcept
2018/03/1505:49:13Kousei23->plucking23
2018/03/1320:18:17Beachguy->whoismoses
2018/03/1314:15:12Cassius->vizsafe
2018/03/1207:06:03bitkilo->MemoryDealers
2018/03/1016:30:07biodieselchris->cheddur_announce
2018/03/0916:51:32spartak_t->batesresearch
2018/03/0912:09:54batesresearch->spartak_t
2018/03/0714:20:44PistonHonda->Kreds
2018/03/0714:19:19PistonHonda->mistercashking
2018/03/0619:18:56negeroy->satoshi
2018/03/0617:00:50CryptoCanary->crackfoo
2018/03/0606:47:38nrigo->gawlea
2018/03/0512:24:14Seccour->laszlo
2018/03/0411:12:07Greaves7->ATMcoin
2018/03/0319:31:31SparkyU->BarkingHawk
2018/03/0316:45:53HCLivess->baritus
2018/03/0316:45:38HCLivess->Tranz
2018/03/0310:05:48kliown->babicena14
2018/03/0307:40:46TheNewAnon135246->romanornr
2018/03/0223:12:52ancientcoins->ATMcoin
2018/03/0218:22:35BernieCoin->crackfoo
2018/02/2817:37:03taxmanmt5->pokerowned
2018/02/2809:40:24Wendigo->NLNico
2018/02/2721:20:33Claymore->satoshi
2018/02/2719:01:32Wendigo->ibminer
2018/02/2707:33:56BioMike->brobbel
2018/02/2700:30:25casinobitco->SyGambler
2018/02/2614:43:31CryptInvest->mthcl
2018/02/2523:44:52NoctisConnor->DrGuns4Hands
2018/02/2417:47:23Southpaw0->zazarb
2018/02/2311:30:14spartacusrex->monsterer2
2018/02/2306:46:59truimpheriues->TheBobyHunter
2018/02/2303:00:14peteycamey->Rhego
2018/02/2205:50:41superscommessebitcoin->Patron92
2018/02/2101:12:39bitcasino.io->blue_way
2018/02/2012:27:55flyer88->q(O_O)p
2018/02/1901:03:11marcus_of_augustus->infofront
2018/02/1811:55:12MICRO->aleksej996
2018/02/1811:37:58hurricandave->sidehack
2018/02/1721:38:55mindrust->Royse777
2018/02/1619:52:18BayAreaCoins->dooglus
2018/02/1613:50:44hrbt->xiao2017
2018/02/1522:25:071369->TrollCoins
2018/02/1522:23:491369->AllarDallar
2018/02/1522:23:171369->youngwebs
2018/02/1521:15:19hrbt->masstahcoiner
2018/02/1518:01:31talatk->pitipawn
2018/02/1512:39:25Alondre->Evil-Knievel
2018/02/1512:26:38schnF6tzel->Evil-Knievel
2018/02/1510:00:49Gizfreak->EverGreenCoin
2018/02/1502:22:26Decoded->JetCash
2018/02/1420:39:37narousberg->D3Pool
2018/02/1416:33:51hrbt->cryptoworld2017
2018/02/1316:05:06AbraxasCcs->analema
2018/02/1300:49:17oblox->FrozenChaos
2018/02/1207:56:30goraset->the_doctor
2018/02/1118:29:21oblox->Herbert2020
2018/02/1113:41:07Bittzy78->kaptkrunch
2018/02/1015:14:57naypalm->GameKyuubi
2018/02/0919:23:07chickenado->Chachacoin17
2018/02/0918:59:34thend1949->Chachacoin17
2018/02/0911:41:41marcuslong->Chachacoin17
2018/02/0911:10:45CasinoBetGame->TheBobyHunter
2018/02/0821:48:01s1lverbox->Arczimedes
2018/02/0820:34:13Jasad->fine99
2018/02/0802:20:58Chase->DNotes
2018/02/0723:59:58e1ghtSpace->chrysophylax
2018/02/0716:52:11oxilore->negeroy
2018/02/0714:46:30RHavar->devans
2018/02/0706:52:01sonerbo->whisee
2018/02/0701:05:40DNotes->Dyna
2018/02/0616:55:22MICRO->EnF0Rc3r
2018/02/0613:56:43Lyricz->scaramanga1337
2018/02/0611:13:26pinkmanfreespirit->hkdfgkdf
2018/02/0514:49:29Jonesd->romanornr
2018/02/0513:51:53TwinWinNerD->BitPanda.com
2018/02/0505:45:52Twinscoin2017->Ronaldcoin2017
2018/02/0501:51:24shapeshiftscam->RichDaniel
2018/02/0423:02:59bitkilo->zazarb