Mining profitability these days are low compare 3 months ago and any stats online is not accurate even the whattomine is not accurate.

Can you try this pool https://ethermine.org/ Because I tried this it gives higher payout than mining pool hub base on what I experienced.

Then you can try the other miner listed on ethermine.org both claymore and ethminer gives me same hashrate. However, I stay use claymore because I can use more option and commands than ethminer.