Post
Topic
Board Bitcoin Discussion
Re: ATTENTION: Any exchange right now can act like a bank
by
Jered Kenna (TradeHill)
on 04/07/2011, 04:40:55 UTC

If everyone knows the exchange has a fractional reserve it's not a bad thing.
If they're doing it without saying so that's another issue.

We've talked about doing something along those lines (the wallets).
I don't write the code so I'm not sure how difficult it would be to have individual wallets.
I would be interested in any solutions people can come up with though.

-Jered
 

The system is useful because it provides transparency. The question of whether fractional reserves are desirable is not relevant.
Transparency is useful with a fractional reserve too.

E.g.
Suppose that the exchange promises to hold a minimum of 30% as a BTC reserve against all its bitcoin liabilities. Each customer is assigned a unique block explorer address that holds exactly 30% of their account balance.

If this account is not at exactly 30% of the account balance, then the customer will know that either:
a) the exchange has been hacked, or
b) the exchange is not holding a 30% BTC reserve.

Again, customers should be able to audit exchanges using block explorer. That is what the technology is there for.



Your turning an exchange into a bank, which isn't what we want, though with this you can also do what your saying as well.

Not sure if that's directed at me or cunicula. We're holding 100% and if we move away from that we'll make it very clear with enough time to pull out if you want.
Currently that isn't in the plans.