My initial plan was to allow each investor to choose their own house edge and risk level and have them form a market like on an exchange, so the player gets matched by whichever investor(s) are offering the lowest house edge(s). This would result in competition between investors to get gambler action and cause the edge to be the lowest available anywhere. I wonder how such an idea would go down. It would probably result in a few crazy investors offering very low edges, and leave the sensible investors getting matched by none but the biggest bets. (Like how when you ask for more than the current market rate on MtGox when selling coins, you only get matched by the big buy orders).
Doog I plead you not to do this. The market will keep getting undercut until house edge is very low. I know this will attract more gambler, but it'll kill site profit (yours and mine).
1% is already very competitive and clearly allows the gambler to win big anyway.