I'm going to take ghedipunk's advice and just post everything up needed to do the job.

Here is a link to the whole plugin I need modified: http://www.filedropper.com/2012-06-25wp2pgpmail-pro
This will install in any wordpress.

I need you to:

1) Remove all form names in the output email. Right now I get:

name: Joe Smith
address: 18 Nickel Lane
City-state-zip: Nowhere, NJ, 37362

I would like:
Joe Smith
18 Nickel Lane
Nowhere, NJ 37362

2) I would like the "from" field in the email to not be encrypted, but to show their email address

 I will pay .5btc for doing this (or .25btc if you can only do one). You can PM me here. Show me a working version on your site and I will pay you and you can send me the files after. I will post up here when the task has been completed. If you are actively working on it with an ETA let me know and I can post that here as well.