We decided to change format of ICO investigation process. We now have due diligence page for active/upcoming ICOs. You can find it here
https://tokensrecord.com/ico-due-diligence.
The page looks like this

There is a set of criterias that could be more or less certainly identified that you can check in the web.
Details about what we do and how you can read in the article on medium:
ICO due diligence and review procedure