Am quoting mdayonliner, but my question is directed towards Astargath
I guess you are seeing the rating depending on your personal trust setting. It's different for sure for others. i.e I see green for BayAreaCoins, OgNasty, TMAN.
mprep is the same for me...
Click here if unable to see imageI only have Tomatocage removed from my trust list and this is what I see:

But who are you really Astargath? Or, rather, what is your main alt? There's a few of these "trust" themed threads popping up recently started by sock puppets.
See, this is why people is afraid to speak up, what do you mean who am I really and why would you think this is not my main alt lol, I have like 3k posts here. I have default trust, I never changed the settings and I see that too. You don't think it's weird for a global mod to have negative trust? You and tomatocage also seem to have a negative trust battle as well. I'm just saying that trust is a bit meaningless if people are just going to give it based on personal feelings.