actually, i dont think it works very well. back in the day you had to actually scam somebody and the buyer had to prove you scammed. nowadays any idiot can say your a scammer even if a scam never happened.
i like the old way better.
The new system might generate a few false positives (I haven't formed a personal opinion about what happened between you and Goat), but the old system had too many false negatives. THeymos was the only person handing out scammer tags, so it was him against thousands of scammers...