Ok, after the wallet resynced, my balance now shows correct.
My concern now is, how did I end up not synced with the chain in the first place for this to occur? Seems my wallet was open with status of synced and staking for almost 2 full months when in reality, it wasn't synced, nor staking, not to the right chain anyways.
I don't see how deleting the database and redownloading it was any resolution to how the issue occured to begin with. How could I stake and get reward up until April 18th and then all of a sudden end up behind and transactions not going to the block explorer? I hadn't changed anything from when they were counting until when they weren't.
Seems bizarre to me.