I agree, this guy should definitely be pursued legally. Clearly he is not really interested in getting his BTC back, which I believe is a lie anyway. He maliciously wants to disrupt Cryptsy's business and seems to be succeeding. Even if the case wasn't won at least it would teach the fool a lesson with $10k's of legal defense..
You guys tell each other what ever makes you all feel better. All I did was simply call the AG on Tuesday, explain to them I have more than $50K in limbo on an unregulated crypto exchange operating in Florida and they asked if I could come up in person on Thursday, which I certainly did. They asked me if I could prove any of it and I did indeed. TXID's were part of my explanation and demo. So far in the past three days I have recovered about 41 BTC or so of my coins that were in limbo. I in no way gave any false information or defamatory statements. All the AG is going to do is take a serious look and interest in this because it is happening in Florida and there are some Florida citizens potentially at risk here. If Cryptsy gets closed down, so be it. That means they weren't as squeaky clean as they claim.
The kicker in all of this, is that I wasn't even demanding for Cryptsy to return my coins now or anything, all I wanted was an explanation, which none of us got. Really would it have hurt any of them to have made a post here. For all those asking, YES I made several tickets and got unrelated canned responses for replies, IRC Support chat no luck, Twitter nothing, email nothing. Again, whose fault is this?
You can say all you want now, you have already taken the actions. Even if your story about going to the AG is false, your malicious commentary on this thread would be enough for legal action. You should have known that would be an obvious outcome of your actions.