This thread is funny.  If you suspected Fraud from this company, your first step would be to file a criminal complaint with the police that would investigate and then refer the case to onward.  Alternatively, you would contact a lawyer to advise you on your next steps and actions.  If you truly had 63 BTC "lost" on Cryptsy, you could afford such an attorney.  You would not directly take your case or complaint to the Attorney General (assistant or otherwise).  Furthermore, even if you were able file such a complaint, kudos' to Cryptsy and Florida for you being able to do so.  Have you tried doing such things with BTC-E, MCXnow, or others?  Cryptsy posts their office information and ownership directly on the website.  Doesn't seem like such a scam, or if it is, it's a really good one that seems to be costing them more than it is earning.

Secondly, Cryptsy seems to be keeping everyone in the loop with what is going on.  I get tweets almost every day of what is happening and the issues that are being experienced, including the huge backlog of support requests that they are getting.  It's not like they are being oblivious to them or not responding.  You can't say the same about some other exchanges.

Finally, this is the wild west at the moment in time for Cryptocurrency.  Companies and sites supporting Cryptocurrencies are going through explosive and unprecedented growth.  You have to EXPECT these type of issues and make your own personal safeguards and judgments.  If you can't stomach the loss you should not be in this market at this time.  I've had minor losses (MCXFees) and huge gains on minimal investments (MasterCoin.org).  I wish I had invested more on my successes but I took the risk that I could stomach to lose and/or gain from it.  You should be treating the Exchanges the same way, Cryptsy or otherwise.

--Perry
aka NeonRonin

PS - I have no official affiliation with Cryptsy, though I do have a vested interest.