btw the hottest one is the one on top and the coolest is the one in bottom, does that make sense?
I played with that yeah
It gets noisy

And doesn't affect the temp

If turning up the fans doesn't affect the temp, then you have a bad fan. From 56% to 100% should drop the temp at least 10C, unless of course the fan isn't running at all, which would explain all of your issues.
I can hear the fans roaring when up to 100 and silent when being 50, so they are definitely working.