I suggest people to read this.
For example Bitcointalk failed at doing their Merit and Trust system fair.
So is this the poutinsev ALT??
I like this article much better than your last. It's actually well thought out and written. I could do without the all caps titles though.
To reiterate from your previous thread.
The merit system may not be perfect but it is far from a failure.
The trust system may not be perfect but it is far from a failure.