That is the exact kind of logic that would make me question their judgement.
Oh, please. You already question the judgement of people who don't approve of your sockpuppetry and the notion that a person can be involved in a deal and also escrow the deal--and whether you question that judgement or not is absolutely irrelevant to any of the people with brains on bitcointalk, because they already know not to deal with you, because of
your shoddy judgement. And I would say that's accurately reflected in your feedback score.