What I do know is that there have been 0 accounts recovered in the last Ca. 1 year?
Do you?
No he doesn't, there have been quite a few accounts reported to have been recovered so far...
plus why would he check my post history? activity? and timezone? yo are saying only "selected" members are now entitled for recovery? lol.
ip logs are also redundant imo. and NoI do not think they check all that- infact they check NOTHING a big NOTHING

I'm saying that theymos claimed that he does a lot more than verifying a signed message and that he has limited time. It doesn't matter if you believe or not. End of the story.
You could've posted an address and then later posted the private key to that address somewhere as a competition or something, he'd have to check that.
He also has to chekc that you haven't sent out a loan or something...