Still, there is a difference between 300 reports where 1/4 are good, and 3/4 are good. That difference increases at 2,000 reports...
I agree a small number of inaccurate reports don't mean anything - but should someone who posts 1,000 spam reports wear the same badge as someone who posts 1,000 accurate reports?
I don't theymos is planning to include bad or unhanded reports in the badge calculation. From OP:
Maybe one for 300 good reports, one of 1000, and one for 5000
Yeah, I think good reports will only be taken into consideration. Otherwise people wouldn't care what they reported good or bad as long as it counted towards their badge.
I'll probably add it next week sometime.
What happened to this statement?
These badges will be cool and all, but they're pretty far down on the list of things I'd like to see implemented here. I would much rather more mods be added (or current ones promoted to dedicated sub mods), and more importantly signatures removed from Newbs and Juniors and/or a merit requirement added for the latter.
I like them, but they're too hard to distinguish between.