I think it will be great to choose trading, they are both profitable but the trading process is way more better in mining in terms of high income and feasible result.
Mining is most subject in scam schemes which is very alarming and very difficult to trust with in this industry.
compared to mining trading, it is more able to be used by many people with whatever money capital and do not have to use complete equipment. so I think trading can be used as a safe way to get profit if done properly and carefully.