I am a newbie, I want to clearly state my opinion on meriting.
The idea of  merits for ranking is  not bad in my opinion, no one needs bullshit in his house. Some say it's being harsh on beginners but it's not, it's actually telling the new guys like me that this is a serious place so no garbage.
The forum needs value from everymember.
Newbies need to understand it and make worthwhile posts. You only get worth you deserve.