I would be far more friendly to you if you found an actual example of an undeserving user but LoyceV... come on, that's just plain stupid. roslinpl's post also deserves every merit it got.
1Even if you had found a proper example that would still be short of actual proof. There is lots of merit data available. You could start by analyzing that and telling us where you see a bad pattern, as opposed to one or two user accounts. Hint: many capable data nerds (including LoyceV LOL) have done that and haven't reached the conclusion you're angling for.
And while we're using anecdotal evidence to make far-reaching conclusions:
NEWBIE + GOOD POST = IGNORE
I've been giving away free merits for a month now. You can follow the link in my signature to find out that there have been very few attempts to claim them. So I'm gonna file your claim under "utterly debunked".
1 - posts in OP's screenshots:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1727100https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1926895https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=3078328