Fair enough, we all have our own opinions, i'm not going to tell you what to do, the stats to me look extremely like what my miners say, and the payout, for me at least, is either equal to or higher than what I get on other pools.

Now i'm not saying they aren't scamming with 100% certainty, but if you feel that they are, you can go to another pool and see if what kind of pay you get. The real difference is from personal experience, I've always had issues with other pols, specifically pools with PPLNS payouts, and when I started mining here, all those issues were gone.