So what should happen to a baby born in the US to an American citizen father and a non American citizen mother?
Sounds like a pretty unique circumstance that could be interpreted by the courts if they were to go back to the original definition, or at least the definition that the author was trying to get across, as was stated before!
Good question though.
I'm curious on your position on this situation tbh. Would you consider the baby to be an American citizen if birthright citizenship was revoked?