Has anyone ever accused you of being Satoshi? If not, please allow me the honor of being the first! 
Actually, I think you are possibly the first individual to ask me this directly.
I'm not Satoshi. I've just been around since early 2010 and I fall into this category: http://gavinandresen.ninja/not-as-many-as-you-think
I'm a truly random person to the Bitcoin project and thus my messages with Satoshi were equally so. Perhaps I gained some insights that others did not in this regard.
I would say probably so as you were there as it was happening... your perspective on how things went down is different from people who can only absorb his conversations years afterward.
What's your take on his current "reappearance," referring to the new post on the P2P Foundation page? Probably meaningless, right?