What I was surprised about is that the price paid out per share is different almost to each user
This statement is in contradiction with previous note that "most members are being paid appropriately".
Not if you understand that each person has a different situation depending on the adjustments they received. You can be paid appropriately depending on adjustments but that per share amount would be different than someone who had no adjustments.
"price paid out per share" should have nothing to do with each member's "adjustments" due to loans, penalties, etc.
Dividend per share and "price paid out per share" is equal for each member of this GB. We need to be shown calculation on what dividend per share is and a separate calculation on how adjustment for each user is done.
It's just this simple.