What examples can you show of well written posts that you profoundly disagreed with, and you gave merits to?
Quickseller's
post about Kavanaugh for example. A few other posts in P&S as well, just can't find links quickly.
You are right. I was too narrow in the way I said it because it does happen on occasion but I still believe it is not the norm.
I also need to work on not saying "you" so much in my posts or addressing a certain other poster like that because I certainly don't mean/want to put a specific person on the spot like that, usually..
I should have said something more like - "How many merited posts do you all see merited for quality of writing and effort despite the sender profoundly disagreeing with the message of the post they merited?"
I think it is natural for us to use merit as a "+1", or a "Yeah, what he said." to show our support for a well placed message that we want to back up as an endorsement.
Or even something funny but low effort, just whatever we enjoy.
Try sarcasm, that's the real
money Merit maker

It's very true and natural for us to do and I don't think it is wrong to do so, but I can see why someone from another perspective who thinks it's not so funny would feel butthurt seeing a low effort post get merited.
User eddie13 - (0.4973 Merit per new post)
Hey, that's pretty good but look at this one..
181.
eddie13 earned
191 50 Merit from outside the Top 200 Merit Receivers
181.
eddie13 earned
191 27 Merit from outside the Top 500 Merit Receivers
My stats there are abysmal! (If the ratio means something bad like some perspectives seem to think.)
If you're not a Merit source yet, I think you should apply!
I might some day..