I am on the fence if he even agrees with the positions he takes. It is possible he (and a few others) are going to extreme lengths to criticize certain people, so that legit criticism of these people are assumed to be trolling and are ignored.
Even if there's legitimate criticism somewhere in all of his rambling, he's made his point many times over and at this point everything he's writing is just trolling. If the community thought he had valid points, he'd have garnered some support but that doesn't seem to be happening--and he just doesn't grasp that.
It is my opinion that the negative ratings others have given him are inappropriate for a number of reasons. First of all, he does not appear to trade with anyone, so leaving the negative ratings will not actually warn anyone against doing business with him. Secondly, the negative ratings only give him more to complain about. Lastly, I don't think him trolling is an indication that he is a scammer.
Negative trust isn't just given to scammers, and you know that. If Theymos thinks members ought to leave negs ONLY for people scamming or suspected of scamming, then he would make a rule requiring that. As far as CH is concerned, he's spreading lies and breaking rules and other DT members are fed up with it. I don't blame them for giving him a neg.
My prediction is he will eventually get banned for trolling
That would be nice. He's one of the worst trolls I've seen since I've been a member here, and not because of his attacks against me. It's because of his constant derailing of threads, repetition of the same nonsense over and over, and his obvious use of alt accounts to give the illusion that someone agrees with him (Chosen Username is the first one that comes to mind, but there may be others). It's time for him to go.