I just hope JusticeforYou can find an old usb drive with the backup for the lost private keys. I'm not sure what to think of the red tag.

-snip-
The only reason for which he was not tagged
sooner is his rank. Had it been a normal member they would long have been red (all the prior discussed things considered).
-snip-
However, I'm not certain IP addresses from years ago mean much since many carriers have dynamic IPs.
Correct; it could be the same area though. However, JusticeForYou could simply claim they moved and thus (conveniently, again) aren't in the same area anymore.