Post
Topic
Board Bitcoin Discussion
Re: bitcoin vs solidcoin
by
The Electric Monk
on 01/09/2011, 23:08:10 UTC
The tragedy of these forks is that they're trying to bleed off a few hundred or thousand devotees from a small segment of the tiniest corner of the most marginalized and obscure offshoot of the almost fractally invisible group of geeks and libertarians... and they don't even seem to realize it. Bitcoin just barely has enough people to sustain what bare and sparse economic activity we have. There's not enough to go around for all these forks. I guess the long-term strategy is to eventually convert the entire bitcoin userbase to their own version.

That's fine with me. May the best cryptocurrency win. Problem is, I don't see how solidcoin can attract anyone who is actually worth having. Most people who contribute something significant are already invested in bitcoin (and I mean emotionally, not financially here). Speculators will be attracted to solidcoin but since they don't actually do anything, nobody cares.

Reading those hyperbolic posts the solidcoin folks make on their website really turns me off, though. Have a tiny bit of self-respect, will you? If your clone is good enough it's good enough, nobody is listening to what you have to say about bitcoin, believe me.

Hey, I'm new, and I'm here because I heard about Solidcoin.  I'm not sure if I'm "worth having" but for what it's worth I don't agree with the negative postings about BTC made by one of the SC organizers.  I told them that.

As you pointed out, there's limited interest in BTC right now, but don't think keeping things the same is going to lead to rampant, wide acceptence.  Both chains could be improved and probably replaced by something faster and more user friendly.  I'm currently trying to promote both BTC and SC as I belong to some communities where I think people would find them ideal for their transactions.