I don't think relying on reviews is a solid guide whether a certain ICO/coin is trustworthy. We need to dig deeper and do a background check on the team behind it. Also, if the team's information is not shared publicly, then that would be a BIG RED FLAG for me.
Haven't trusted any new coins of recent because of my experience when i was a bounty hunter and also investor. Last two years to be precise i invested in a new coins that seem good with potentials but what i got backed was horrible as my invested went down to hell. Before i invested into the coin, i read their whitepapers, checked on their team members and their social media profiles did more under ground research but still end in the deep. After this incident i vow not to invest in any new coin again because there are much tendencies for those coins to be scam or shitcoins.