Whether the ICO is a scam or not is irrelevant. The mere fact of the matter is that icoethics and others like you are a discrace! You do no good yourself you just say everything is a scam while sitting in your ivory tower. Sure a lot of ICOs are scams, however you have a growing reputation of being an idiot and discussed in many circles. You jump the gun and say everything is a scam just to make a name for yourself. I have been in 3 groups recently were Icoethics has labeled scam based on nothing. Most people think your an idiot but sometimes the damage you can do to a legitimate ICO is beyond repair. I dont think that is ethical. I actually know someone involved in windhan and know its a legitimate company. You found the website weeks before it was released somehow and branded it a scam while it was underdevelopment. Yours a discrasce! Maybe get a real job and stop trying to bring everyone else down who is actually trying to do something!
They used fake team members and a plagiarized whitepaper. Having a website that is under development is no excuse to use photos of other people without their consent. There is also no excuse for plagiarizing a whitepaper. Both can be considered as an offence/crime. Windham has corrected their mistakes and ICOEthics has redacted their rating, problem solved.
I have never seen them call an ICO a scam without providing the necessary evidence so don't try to portrait them as incompotent or unfair.