I fixed it with a dirty hack for now, probably I'll have to add pages at some point. It's a pain, though, since there are three separate sections which need pages...
What about showing only received feedback by default? A link at the bottom would allow seeing sent feedback on another page (i.e.
?action=senttrust;u=...).
If required, pagination would be enabled independently for the received and sent trust. Regarding the received trust, the first page(s) would show trusted feedback and the next one(s) untrusted feedback. This way only one pagination would be shown at the same time.
This whole split could be activated either for everyone or only after a set threshold of the number of received+sent feedback is reached.