I am using MetaMask, it combines with Brave browser, till now I don't have any issues. It's really a good solution to store eth and erc-20 for me.
Lol, don't mention buddy. Brave + Metamask = Something great and awesome.
Anyways to the OP, personally I'm a fan of MyEtherWallet. It gives me the best experience ever and I love that. Metamask is good as well, have used it a couple of times and have encountered no problems as at now