This would lead me to believe the mods are *not* telling those who are banned which of their posts were found to be plagiarized.
I highly doubt anyone is being told which posts they plagiarized--but that's always the way it's worked. When someone opens a ban appeal thread, only then does someone do the research and come up with an example or multiple examples.
If Bill Gator was not told which post was plagiarized when he was banned, then the question becomes how did the OP know which post he was banned for *before* he opened this thread.
The implication is the OP is not Bill Gator appealing his ban, but rather someone else trying to give an excuse to tag him.