There a couple of useful stats that may help you compile a list of a kind, such as the stats pointed out by @Kakmakr (bear in mind that they are all time, and you cannot delimit them to a shorter timeframe) or https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?action=merit;stats, or even some threads that hint/know which of them may be Merit Sources ([TOP-200] The most generous users giving merits) or DT members (Complete overview of users on DT1 and DT2 and their ratings - which may change periodically).

Even so, I’d say that the compilation of profiles is likely a rather personal matter since it relates to your personal preferences (topics, style and so forth) and even, at some point, to forum political standpoints. For example, looking through the names you provide in the OP, I often read posts by 4 of them, skim through some by 4 more, and currently have one of them on my (short) ignore list.