I think I see where the problem is - you are making assumptions using the wrong data to attempt to make your point.  He is likely talking about other elected reversals much further back in a time series of the pricing move - not the most recent move.  If you look at many of his past charts these elected reversals can be many months or even years apart.

I can't spend the time rummaging through all the data or blog posts - but I'd bet that's the case.