I wonder if we'll get an update from theymos on these. When was the last time they were posted? It would be very interesting to see how the table looks now. I think a couple of users probably deserve a mod spot, especially those with literally thousands of good reports. A new mod or two are probably long-overdue.
For now we have an idea of how many users have 5000+ reports from these very vague stats:
BTW, currently 195 users would have some icon, and only 9 users would have the highest-tier one.
So, at the time of that post only 9 users had more than 5000 reports which is a slight increase from the last detailed statistics theymos posted. I imagine the very top have more than 20k reports now. Definitely some additional moderators needed to fill in for the global moderators which are also covering a dedicated section. I think Bitcoin Discussion probably needs a dedicated mod, and much of the altcoin section.